Skip to main content

tv   Hardball With Chris Matthews  MSNBC  January 16, 2013 11:00pm-12:00am PST

11:00 pm
and work around children. everything we do and i have devoted my entire career to is educate children. so the voices of children who are not afraid to speak their minds are really pure, and they need to be listened to by all the people who make these important decisions. no -- there is no amendment that says that children have a right to grow up healthy and not be shot at. but it is just a given. i -- i ended my speech today talking about you can tell the value of a society by how they treat their children. and i think the horror of this will continue every time people sit down and think about it. that -- 20 little 6 and 7-year-olds could be killed like this. >> dr. janet robinson, the children of newtown are lucky to have you running their system.
11:01 pm
and thank you very much for bringing your voice to washington today and ava's voice, and thank you for joining us tonight. >> thank you, lawrence. >> thank you. >> gun smoke, let's play "hardball." ♪ good evening. i'm chris matthews in washington. let me start tonight with this. my hero, the great world war ii leader winston churchill once said i refuse to be impartial between the fire brigade and fire. president obama agreed. what side will the republicans take? the fires? will the gop be the guns over people party? look at the tough stand the president's taken here. not just limiting the capacity of gun magazines and background checks. but limiting the ban on semiautomatic rifles.
11:02 pm
what's the nra done? gone after the president's daughters. people are hurt by what happened to those first graders. it's not a smart move to be out there backing the gun runners. for sure it's not good to sell in the suburbs or the cities. it may not even sell in the country. nobody likes what happened in connecticut and a decent society will get off its butt. a decent society will get off its butt. both the gun kind and the other kind. collin goddard was a survivor of the 2007 virginia tech shootings. he's now with the brady campaign to prevent gun violence. and mark glazer is the director of mayors against illegal guns. for measures he could control through the executive branch. they range from nominating a permanent atf director to new measures on mental health and school safety and a campaign promoting gun safety for owners. but he also called on congress to take on the problem
11:03 pm
legislatively. >> these are a few of the 23 executive actions that i'm announcing today, but as important as these steps are, they are in no way a substitute for action from members of congress. it's time for congress to require a universal background check for anyone trying to buy a gun. congress should restore a ban on military-style assault weapons and a ten-round limit for magazines. and finally congress needs to help rather than hinder law enforcement as it does its job. we should get tougher on people who buy guns with the express purpose of turning around and selling them to criminals. and we should severely punish anybody who helps them do this. >> collin, what's your reading on what he did today? do enough? >> we finally have leadership from the white house. it's great to see a comprehensive approach to the gun violence. the vice president promised me personally we're going to get something done about this.
11:04 pm
it was a great day. >> when you hear it, what do you see that works? what do you see that will stop people who are mentally unstable or emotionally unstable or criminally intent from getting guns to use in these spray shootings is what we're really concerned with right now. >> that's the biggest way to impact that is at the point of sale and requiring a background check on all gun sales. they realize that background checks don't take guns from law-abiding people. they pass those every time. but those with a felony conviction or a diagnosed mental illness -- >> where's the nra on background checks? >> the vast majority of them -- >> what about the big shots? lapierre? >> i don't know. >> do you think he's for this stuff? >> he should be. >> where are the bad guys in this? they make money off this. may make money off everything we're talking about here. ammo, clips, guns. and background checks prevent sales. >> the truth is most dealers
11:05 pm
want more people in their stores. when these private sales are taking place over the internet or out of the back seat of a car, that doesn't do good. >> so the dealers of brick and mortar want it. >> my dad was a gun dealer. he wanted people in the store. that's how they make their money. >> let me ask you. when you do a background check, a guy comes in and is reasonable looking. they want to buy a gun. if you have a background check, do they have to wait while the government checks out who they are, whether there's a court-ordered mental situation or emotional problem or a criminal record or whatever. what stops them from getting that gun mailed to them ten days or whatever later? >> well, right now they get turned away at the point of sale and are not prosecuted. that's a problem the president ought to deal with. that's the problem the president and we have been talking about for a long time. nothing stops that person from going online, pressing a mouse three times and getting a gun from an unlicensed private seller. >> you can go on ebay and get a
11:06 pm
gun. >> not on ebay. they do a good job not selling guns. armslist and craigslist. >> if somebody says bushmaster 100 bucks used. >> or best offer. here's my phone number and e-mail address. throw me your best offer and let's move somewhere. guns, cash, that's it. >> are either of you educated on what the assault rifle is? >> the president is going to follow the lead of people on the hill. diane feinstein. >> didn't the bushmaster not get defined last time? >> the law did some good, but it was easy to evade. i think they're going to pass a tighter law this time. >> let's talk about politics. you can do these things by geography. but we had ed rendell on who took on the nra in pennsylvania. he said the suburban republic, those who are going to be in
11:07 pm
trouble are those who line up with the nra who represent the suburbs. the suburbs will not put up with this. >> you ask people who are afraid of the nra. name me five congressman or governors who lost their seats because of the nra? >> they're obedient. let's look at this. the president said it will be tough and he'll need the support of republicans and democrats who hold wide ranging views on guns and gun ownership. let's listen to the president. >> we're going to need voices in those areas and those congressional districts where the tradition of gun ownership is strong to spoke up. ask your member of congress if they support universal background checks to keep guns out of the wrong hands. ask if they support a ban on high capacity magazines and military style weapons. and if they say no, ask them why not. ask them what's more important? doing whatever it takes to get a
11:08 pm
"a" grade from the gun lobby that funds their campaigns or giving parents some peace of mind when they drop their child off for first grade. >> speaking of which the nra responded to the action plan today by saying in part, we look forward to working with congress on a bipartisan basis to find real solutions to protecting america's most valuable asset, our children. attacking firearms and ignoring children is not a solution to the crisis we face as a nation. only law-abiding gun owners will affected and our children will remain vulnerable to the inevitability of more tragedy. that came after hours the nra did this web video mentioning the president's two daughters. >> are the president's kids more important than yours? then why is he skeptical about putting armed security in our schools when his kids are protected by armed guards at their school?
11:09 pm
>> i don't know where to go with this indecency. i'll start with you, collin. what do you make of that ad? i don't know what that helps. >> either do i. it's a ridiculous statement and to attack the president's children like that when there's more policy we should be discussing. i frankly don't get it. >> does the nra notice we've had presidents mowed down and their families vulnerable. lincoln and garfield and teddy roosevelt shot at. luckily to be saved. truman was attacked. roosevelt was shot at. kennedy was killed. reagan was almost killed. it's not a joke. >> what this goes to is the big and growing difference between the nra's rank and file who are pretty normal people. >> do they know that the idea of talking about assassinating or endangering the lives of a presidential family hurts the process. then to say let's talk about this daughters.
11:10 pm
>> there's a lot of nra members who don't like this kind of stuff. they're not talking to their rank and file. they're talking to a hard core base right now. i don't know that's a winning strategy for them over the long haul. >> what is going on? lapierre used to seem his head was screwed on a couple years ago. maybe many years ago. why are they sending him out with this absolute rejectionist position? we're not doing anything on gun clips or background checks. why don't say they you know what? there's common ground here. >> we know that their membership supports what we're talking about. background checks on all gun sales. that speaks to that giant disconnect between the membership of the leadership. these are clearly out of touch from the american person, the further away from reality they're going to get. >> next to the president and his remarks today, slightly older than the newtown students. these children had all written letters to the president calling for action on gun control. which i expect young kids would do.
11:11 pm
in advance of these coming to washington, rush limbaugh accused the president of using those kids as human shields. let's listen. >> obama uses kids as human shields. he brings these kids supposedly who wrote letters to the white house after newtown. it's going to be very difficult, very difficult to oppose it. you've got these little kids there. they don't want to die. and how can you not listen to them. you've got to do something. that's the picture. >> what kind of -- >> is he on or off his meds again? >> i don't care about his meds. i care about the lack of any kind of human approach to this problem. kids were mowed down by a deranged killer. he had a weapon that was particularly dangerous and particularly useful in a sick way to somebody who wants to mow people down. semiautomatic bushmaster with clips on it.
11:12 pm
this is a problem we've got to deal with. there could be different ways, but to make fun of those kids, i don't want to die is some kind of joke? that's sadistic. >> rush limbaugh needs to -- >> i don't know why his viewers ride around in cars and trucks doing their jobs, regular people. that's wrong. stop that. we can be for lower taxes, less government, less regulation. we can agree on that. but that is sick. why don't they call him up and say shut up once in awhile. your thoughts? >> they should. and if rush limbaugh actually saw that classroom after that morning, the reality of the situation that we're talking about. >> two to eleven bullets in each kid. unrecognizable children. remember being in first grade? >> i have a son who's there. >> we all remember it a little bit. in a powerful moment today the president spoke about meeting the parents of newtown victim grace mcdonnell. there she is. let's take a look.
11:13 pm
>> grace was seven years old when she was struck down. just a gorgeous, caring, joyful little girl. i'm told she loved pink. she loved the beach. she dreamed of becoming a painter. chris, her father, gave me one of her paintings. and i hung it in my private study just off the oval office. and every time i look at that painting, i think about grace. and i think about the life that she lived and the life that lay ahead of her. and most of all i think about how when it comes to protecting the most vulnerable among us, we must act now. >> you know, i think the responsibility of officials to protect the society. they're doing their jobs. for rush and those people to come out and say this is all theater, nobody made up this crime, this horror.
11:14 pm
nobody made it up. it's true. it's reality. it's the world we live in. and it's going to happen again. i thought it was interesting that the nra put out the phrase referring to the inevitability of this happening again. some guy standing with a uniform on at the school might in some cases stop it. i'm not going to fight that one. but the real problem is the weaponry and the mental illness involved in this case and the ease to buy a weapon and bring it into a school. you know, they keep saying more fire power is going to solve the problem. what do you think? you've been there. >> if the united states the country with 300 million guns already, they allow everybody to carry guns everywhere. if the idea that if only we had more guns that we would be safer. then we would be the safest place in the world. we are the opposite of that. how many hundred million more guns do we need before things are safer for everybody? >> thank you for coming on the
11:15 pm
show. this is an issue not going away. coming up with the nra taking the low road on guns bringing the president's daughters into the debate. says it's time for the republican party, his party, to choose. guns or people. whose side are they on. really on. president obama also has big battles looming over the debt ceiling, budget, immigration. he's already taking heat over the makeup of his cabinet. not enough women. let's talk about that later in the show. and none of the president's second term agenda will be easy with the republicans in congress. take texas congressman steve stockman. he replaced ron paul and is making noise about impeaching the president. it's his second go around in congress. in '94 he was considered far to the right. now he fits in with some of these people. it says a lot how far they have come. finally let me finish with a need for republicans again to choose sides. the wild bunch or the posse? this is "hardball," the place for politics.
11:16 pm
11:17 pm
coming up monday, president obama will deliver his second inaugural address as president. four years ago in his first address, the president paid tribute to the historic nature of his election. >> this is the meaning of our liberty and our creed why men and women and children of every race and every faith can join in celebration across this magnificent mall and why a man whose father less than 60 years ago might not have been served at a local restaurant can now stand before you to take a most sacred oath. >> call me a romantic but, i'm looking for a major even historical address this coming monday. and we'll be right back.
11:18 pm
11:19 pm
welcome back to "hardball." just how out of touch is the nra? the gun rights group has given no ground since the newtown school shooting and is now running a new ad that goes after the president's daughters.
11:20 pm
has the group finally given up the veneer of having from both parties? americans are generally turning on them and many of their policies are deeply unpopular. i'm talking about the nra. and they're facing right now, we'll see. will the republican party go along the same road the nra is taking? joining me now is my friend and colleague joe scarborough who often speaks common sense from the center right. is it fair to say you're in the center right politically? where would you like to have a third party describe you? i think you are center right. i'm somewhere over to the left, but i think you're somewhere on the other side of the middle point. where are you? >> you know, for the most part i'm where i was when i was in congress. 95% conservative rating. and we could start a debate right now over debt. let me just -- because this is an important point to make. entitlements, why the democrats haven't passed a budget in over
11:21 pm
1500 days and you would say this guy is really conservative. we could debate further about government shutdowns and i would tell you i might not flinch in 2013 more than i did in 1995. i'm a really conservative guy especially fiscally. that said, the extremism that has taken over my party on certain issues that has us running down rabbit trails that neither ronald reagan or william f. buckley would ever run down is what's causing this party problems. i think i'm a very conservative guy, but i think my party has gone in a direction that's deeply disturbing to me on a lot of issues especially this one right now. >> traditional this conservative means you believe in institutions and holding them together and holding society together. it's about keeping order. it's about opposing disruptions and radicalism. maybe this is too much like shooting ducks --
11:22 pm
>> no, no. can i make a point on that, though, really quickly though? >> sure. >> this is what's most disturbing to me. i said it before when i came out supporting a ban on assault weapons. you know, for me this issue used to be a symbolic issue. but after newtown, after colorado, after oregon. after everything that's happened it's not about symbolism anymore. and when i really get into a debate and ask a question that the president asked, why? and when i really get into a debate and ask a question that the president asked, why?
11:23 pm
nothing conservative about this point of view this is not about ronald reagan >> let's talk about their leadership with the nra. look at this ad that ran. it's a web ad. didn't spend much money on this baby. you can tell by the quality of it. but let's talk about taste and political sensitivity. not soft sensitivity but smart sensitivity. do they have a grip on the american conscience or not? here is the ad. >> are the president's kids more important than yours? then why is he skeptical about putting armed security in our schools when his kids are protected by armed guards at their school?
11:24 pm
>> what do you make of that ad in terms of political smarts? going after the daughters and their security. >> what i make of the ad is and i said it before. wayne lapierre has done more to hurt the gun rights cause in america than anybody else. start with the press conference. it was a stunningly tone deaf press conferences. one of the most tone deaf press conferences i've seen in my life. then you follow it up with the iphone app that childrens ages four and older could actually practice using assault weapons on target practice on their parents' iphone. then they follow-up with this commercial. chris, there's a reason why even a week after newtown the majority of americans did not support an assault weapons ban. now 60% of americans support an assault weapons ban. 85% of americans want universal background checks. something like 70% of americans actually want a national registration process to track gun sales. and then you go to other issues like high capacity magazines,
11:25 pm
that's like a 65%, 70% approval rating. the nra is upside down in their approval rating. that's all changed over the past two, three weeks. why has it changed? it hasn't changed because of bloomberg. it hasn't changed because of obama. it hasn't changed because of feinstein. it's changed because of the extremism inside the nra leadership. not nra members, but their nra membership has become so extreme they've lost middle america. >> let's talk about whipping this if you're on the republican side and you were among the independents pushing for this on the republican side. when you look at the rural areas, utah, idaho, maybe parts of the south, definitely some parts of the south where you have a real red situation. where the only thing you fear is a primary. a younger man or woman running against you. is there any way they don't consider the pro-gun vote the safe vote? or will that change? is that still the vote voting with the nra? >> i think that's the safest vote. at the same time i can tell you
11:26 pm
there are millions and millions of dollars that are going to be pouring into swing districts across america. not just from michael bloomberg but obviously from gabby giffords' efforts and others. and you're going to see whatever money the nra spends in 2014 you'll see that double, triple, quadrupled from people who support sensible gun control. so what once was the safe vote in a lot of districts is no longer going to be the safe vote. and i can tell you, chris, i know a thing or two about politics. republicans got angry with me over the past year when i told them mitt romney was in trouble. i can tell you something. in 2014 in my district in northwest florida, a district jerry caldwell well called the most conservative in america, there's no doubt this would be the right move for me to run as a fiscally conservative republican, a pro-life republican who has said enough to survivalists and extremists.
11:27 pm
the second amendment is about protecting our homes and hunting with our friends and family members. it's not about military-styled assault weapons that ended up killing, you know, 6-year-old and 7-year-old kids in connecticut. >> i'm on your side. thank you joe scarborough. and his rating, it's always been an independent. up next, how does bill clinton see his relationship with hillary? there is a fascinating tease. big bill speaks out on hillary. and this is "hardball," the place for politics. [ female announcer ] going to sleep may be easy, but when you wake up
11:28 pm
in the middle of the night it can be frustrating. it's hard to turn off and go back to sleep. intermezzo is the first and only prescription sleep aid approved for use as needed in the middle of the night when you can't get back to sleep. it's an effective sleep medicine you don't take before bedtime. take it in bed only when you need it and have at least four hours left for sleep. do not take intermezzo if you have had an allergic reaction to drugs containing zolpidem, such as ambien. allergic reactions such as shortness of breath or swelling of your tongue or throat may occur and may be fatal. intermezzo should not be taken if you have taken another sleep medicine at bedtime or in the middle of the night or drank alcohol that day. do not drive or operate machinery until at least 4 hours after taking intermezzo and you're fully awake. driving, eating, or engaging in other activities while not fully awake without remembering the event the next day have been reported. abnormal behaviors may include aggressiveness, agitation,
11:29 pm
hallucinations, or confusion. alcohol or taking other medicines that make you sleepy may increase these risks. in depressed patients, worsening of depression, including risk of suicide, may occur. intermezzo, like most sleep medicines, has some risk of dependency. common side effects are headache, nausea, and fatigue. so if you suffer from middle-of-the-night insomnia, ask your doctor about intermezzo and return to sleep again. ♪
11:30 pm
president obama's inaugural parade will feature eight floats including a hawaii float to honor his birthplace, an illinois float to honor the first lady's home state and a
11:31 pm
kenyan float just to mess with republicans. why not? it's a parade. everyone loves a parade. back to "hardball." bill clinton answers a question about hillary clinton's health and her plans for the future and thoughts about what lies ahead for their relationship. >> she's always been very, very healthy. and she has very low blood pressure, very low standing heart beat. i tell her she's still got time to have three more husbands after me. whenever i am stubborn about something in her constant quest at my self-improvement, she refers to me as her first husband. because i told her once she was going to live to be 120 and have time for plenty more. >> critics laughed. they can laugh, but it works. not just big bill's pattern there but the whole thing. the whole clinton thing. it works. just think about it. the secretary of state also scored an endorsement of "snl" seth meyers.
11:32 pm
he nominated her for gq's list of hundred hottest women of the century. quote, i think somebody who is getting sexier every year is hillary clinton. every year she seems better at whatever she's doing. she'll have it locked down. from the national endowment from the humanities that will provide new books for a community college library in his own district. well, hint. the title of the grant program is bridging cultures books help muslim journeys. and the congressman walter jones of north carolina asked a christian group to offset that donation with its own set of books. >> i respect all religions and all faiths, but i want them treated fairly. i think too many times the christian faith is not treated fairly. if they want to have books about the muslim faith, let's have equal books about the christian. i'd rather see the $150 million spent to remodel schools in
11:33 pm
craven county or build schools at craven community. >> well, there's been no outcry at that school over a lack of christian reading material at the school. on top of that he says he wants the $150 million to go to other projects. here's the thing. that $150 million is the entire budget, not just this project. he's got that all wrong. and if helping communities in need why did he vote against the sandy relief aid? finally now matter how rational president obama is, the extreme end of the pro gun side will always hear something like this courtesy of jimmy kimmel this time. >> why does president obama want to take everybody's guns away? >> everybody's guns are going to be taken away. >> that's right. the federal government is about to take your guns away.
11:34 pm
>> the federal government's about to take all your guns away. >> whose guns? >> everybody's guns. >> how many guns? >> all your guns. >> call the white house right now because if you don't -- >> here it comes. >> -- here it comes. paid for by americans against context. >> people are going to believe in that. i was just kidding. up next, among the challenges facing president obama in his second term, criticism by some on the makeup of his cabinet. not enough women. and that's ahead. you're watching "hardball," the place for politics. she keeps you guessing. it's part of what you love about her. but your erectile dysfunction - you know, that could be a question of blood flow. cialis tadalafil for daily use helps you be ready anytime the moment's right. you can be more confident in your ability to be ready. and the same cialis is the only daily ed tablet approved to treat ed and symptoms of bph, like needing to go frequently or urgently. tell your doctor about all your medical conditions and medications, and ask if your heart is healthy enough for sexual activity.
11:35 pm
do not take cialis if you take nitrates for chest pain, as this may cause an unsafe drop in blood pressure. do not drink alcohol in excess with cialis. side effects may include headache, upset stomach, delayed backache or muscle ache. to avoid long-term injury, seek immediate medical help for an erection lasting more than four hours. if you have any sudden decrease or loss in hearing or vision, or if you have any allergic reactions such as rash, hives, swelling of the lips, tongue or throat, or difficulty breathing or swallowing, stop taking cialis and get medical help right away. ask your doctor about cialis for daily use and a 30-tablet free trial.
11:36 pm
11:37 pm
11:38 pm
back to "hardball." ♪ welcome back to "hardball." the white house has come under a lot of criticism over the gender makeup of its political appointments. white men occupy many of the senior positions in the white house right now. so far the president has announced he'd filled three major vacancies in his cabinet with white men. today politico and others are reporting the next is dennis mcdonough. another white male. here's one what official told the hill today.
11:39 pm
obviously this person spoke on background not to be named. quote, i work in this administration and i have to admit i'm slightly annoyed by lack of women around him. i mean, come on. out of all those people there's one woman in the room? you mean to tell me there's not one woman to be secretary of staff? earlier this week, let's watch the president at the press conference. >> if you think about my first four years, the person who probably had the most influence on my foreign policy was woman. the people who were in charge of moving forward my most important domestic initiative, health care, were women. the person in charge of our homeland security was woman. my two appointments to the supreme court were women. and 50% of my white house staff
11:40 pm
were women. so i think people should expect that that record will be built upon during the next four years. >> well, is the criticism fair against the president that's been thrown at him? falling short of his problem of being a champion for women. howard fineman is an msnbc political analyst. and "huffington post" has been facing obama. the road forward. and dee dee meyers. you were kind of a pioneers in all this. i watch this. and maybe there's tokenism. which is maybe better than nothing. you wonder about the decision how they made it to make it look good. what's better to make it look bad by not doing it or to look good when you don't intend to have that person in there? >> the best is to put people in with the best authority and do it right.
11:41 pm
i think the president's -- >> why is it happening? >> i think the president makes a good case. that he has appointed a lot of women to senior positions and to unprecedented positions. 43% to the bench were women. >> the numbers are right. but what about paramount -- the prominence of the positions that they're in in the executive branch. >> i think in the cabinet in the first term. so i think the president sends mixed signals. on the one hand he has done, i think, a really good job from a distance of putting together a really diverse team. but when you get closer and see who's around him every day it gets complicated. his body language doesn't always sync up. and when he's in his spare time you get the sense he's more comfortable with men. he's played 132 rounds of golf in four years.
11:42 pm
two of them have been women. i don't want to begrudge the guy if you want to go off with the guys. >> it's an interesting crossover. howard, you on this. i don't know the president personally. i've met him four or five times but i don't know him personally. but i read his friends or old friends which is a safe way to be, keep the old friends who keep your confidence you can have fun times with but you can talk to old buddies that way. he hasn't brought those old buddies into the administration except for valerie. most friends in chicago are not who he works with. he's not using friendship to pick people from? >> now that you mention it, the irony is the one chicago friend that he brought into the inner circle of his white house staff was a woman, valerie jarrett. the others are men, african-american men. >> is he picking from his buddies?
11:43 pm
>> that's the way he is. >> does he do it? >> yes. dee dee mentions the golf games. that doesn't count all the hours watching espn and playing basketball. now, susan rice could probably clean all their clocks. >> she could? >> yeah. she was the captain of her high school basketball team. >> she played in college. >> i like womens basketball. i can follow it. i can identify with it. >> here's something. the president can't complain about this, the white house can't complain about people carping because the president was re-elected as the symbol and leader of this new diverse america. that's who he is. that's what he got congratulated for. that's what "time" magazine named him person of the year for. if there's a picture of him with his inner circle and they're nine white guys and one women, that's bad. >> okay. >> they can't complain. they have to be sensitive of that and all the statistics that dee dee cites don't go to the question of sensitivity about this.
11:44 pm
the questions might not always be fair in the new america he helped create. >> african-american, minority whatever, i say the same thing. you got to spread your name around aggressively. when a job empties, you got two weeks. you better have your face in their face or you're not getting the job. a lot is not being there. if you're not in the room when they're looking, if you're not in the line of sight. the question is for affirmative action purposes shouldn't he be lining up his deputies and make sure there's diversity? maybe not control who works the top jobs. but doesn't he have to fill the magazine of people around him? and he's not done that. >> he has done it in some cases and hasn't in others. for example, there was -- you know, they appointed a new cia director, another white male. highly qualified but nonetheless. there are a number of women running defense agencies in this town that he could have chosen.
11:45 pm
the second was a woman michelle flournoy that he could have chosen. i believe we got to keep pressure on him. because i think this is really important. >> anybody you know that's equally qualified. name some people you know who are equally qualified to the people he named to the top jobs who are women? >> susan rice was. >> equally qualified as john kerry? >> i think so. >> fair enough. >> she was just one. michelle flournoy would have been. >> i think they were just pushing against kerry. against hagel. >> against hagel and be a con train to the president. >> one of the most important people in the president's inner circle in the first term was nancy-ann deparle. had it not been for her they wouldn't have passed the health care bill. she was absolutely indispensable. she's leaving, however.
11:46 pm
>> the great irony is nobody's more powerful in the inner circle than a woman. valerie jarrett. he's known her a long time. she was an executive in chicago. he knows her well. this is an argument we'll have in america and we should always. >> and we'll judge him by the final results. i'll put that out there. >> thank you. up next, press secretary -- let's take a look at the guy who's a far out guy. steve stockman who was an ally when he was first elected and now is in the mainstream of the republican party. the republican party has moved from mainstream conservative to radical.
11:47 pm
11:48 pm
we're coming right back with a curious case of the republican party's lurch to the far right.
11:49 pm
11:50 pm
we want all tools available
11:51 pm
to use, including the impeachment. using children. it reminds me of sadham hussein. >> steve stockton not only threatening to impeach obama, but likening the president to sadham hussein. it was linked back to newt gingrich's republican election back in 1994. his constituents back home and was not re-elected. an article reminded texas voters of stock man's highlights. he suggested president bill clinton planted branch davidian seeds. and he proposed a measure many in congress viewed as bizarre to investigate the famous kinsey report 48 years after its publication. well, mr. stockman is back.
11:52 pm
all of these years later, stockman can still bring the crazy. the problem is he's now just one of many purveyors. joining me now, dana millbank and his senior partner and msnbc political analyst, eugene robinson. there is an animal husbandry as pekt. the people vote -- is it just that we've gotten to a situation in this country where primary is all you've got? if there's a wide field in the primary and a nutty guy wins it, he's in or she's in for life. so if stockman wins a primary, will it with a wide field? crazy after all of these years? >> that's exactly what happened. he was this guy, in the past, he was homeless, eating out of trash cans, had a drug arrest, long rap sheet. they didn't really pay attention. he just got elected in the republican revolution. wait a second, and they got rid of him. you know what, you can't do that anymore. this guy has a safe seat for life. the only way he doesn't get
11:53 pm
reelected is if he gets bumped out in a primary. >> did somebody get to this guy's right? >> the thing is -- you can't. the thing is he's now a member in good standing of the republican caucus. he's not some nut out there. he's in the mainstream. >> i have some sense of taste. some. and when i hear these guys talking about the obama girls being food for discussion here, let's talk about their safety. but then i'm talking about this guy saying the president reminds me of sadham hussein. there he is. and we were all, oh, my god, that kid is scared to death of this guy. >> it's not, by in stretch, the sickest thing he did. he basically accused them of murdering people merely to further his assault gun ban. >> explain how that would work.
11:54 pm
i know a lot of gun people, including my brother, bruce. but here's the question. >> you don't want to follow that. >> how do you organize branch davidian. they organized the raid, but to come up with the idea he justified the raids because he wanted to come out with gun control. it wasn't gun control. >> he said the president wanted them dead because they liked they're guns. >> what about militia members after those two guys were executed? the guys who blew up the oklahoma city. they're dead. and then he celebrates the fact that we've got militias. >> and your point is? i mean, that's who he is. this is -- this guy is -- >> what does he say at town meetings, as opposed to 1994. let's listen. >> like you mentioned, he's putting in all of these executive orders and overstepping his boundaries.
11:55 pm
he continues. could that build up to make a case for possible impeachment? >> all options should be on the table. undoubtedly. >> well, my old buddy, and i mean that term sarcastically, echoed stockman's position in this statement. >> he's one of these guys, isn't he? this is the whole point. the crazy has caught up with him. and it's where our political system has gone. steve stockman hasn't changed at all. >> and frankly, is not doing a service for the republican party. a service to the party would be for the head of the party to draw some lines.
11:56 pm
>> he's too busy organizing. gene, you know he's too busy choreographing. thank you, gene robinson. when we return, let me finish with a need for republicans to choose sides. the wild bunch or the the posse. you're watching "hardball," the place for politics. [ coughs ] ♪ [ male announcer ] you can't let a cold keep you up tonight. vicks nyquil -- powerful nighttime 6-symptom cold & flu relief. ♪ in the middle of the night it can be frustrating. it's hard to turn off and go back to sleep. intermezzo is the first and only prescription sleep aid approved for use as needed in the middle of the night when you can't get back to sleep. it's an effective sleep medicine you don't take before bedtime. take it in bed only when you need it
11:57 pm
and have at least four hours left for sleep. do not take intermezzo if you have had an allergic reaction to drugs containing zolpidem, such as ambien. allergic reactions such as shortness of breath or swelling of your tongue or throat may occur and may be fatal. intermezzo should not be taken if you have taken another sleep medicine at bedtime or in the middle of the night or drank alcohol that day. do not drive or operate machinery until at least 4 hours after taking intermezzo and you're fully awake. driving, eating, or engaging in other activities while not fully awake without remembering the event the next day have been reported. abnormal behaviors may include aggressiveness, agitation, hallucinations, or confusion. alcohol or taking other medicines that make you sleepy may increase these risks. in depressed patients, worsening of depression, including risk of suicide, may occur. intermezzo, like most sleep medicines, has some risk of dependency. common side effects are headache, nausea, and fatigue. so if you suffer from middle-of-the-night insomnia,
11:58 pm
ask your doctor about intermezzo and return to sleep again. ♪ and return to sleep again. i need you. i feel so alone. but you're not alone. i knew you'd come. like i could stay away. you know i can't do this without you. you'll never have to. you're always there for me. shh! i'll get you a rental car. i could also use an umbrella. fall in love with progressive's claims service. this reduced sodium soup says it may help lower cholesterol, how does it work? you just have to eat it as part of your heart healthy diet. step 1. eat the soup. all those veggies and beans, that's what may help lower your cholesterol and -- well that's easy [ male announcer ] progresso. you gotta taste this soup.
11:59 pm